Tunisian
on Fire Spelled ‘Luck' to NY Times Reporter
By Ivan G. Goldman
Emergency personnel and journalists all chase tragedy. The
difference, I can tell you from personal experience, is that medical
technicians, firefighters, and cops, for example, respond by fighting whatever
dark force they’re responding to. The journalist is just there to record it. If
someone’s on fire you don’t smother the flames with a blanket. You snap a
picture.
There’s a conflict of interest between the journalist’s career and his/her
humanitarian instincts. Because the journalist essentially chases the news that
sells, and that is in almost every instance bad news of one sort or another --
fire, flood, murder, mayhem, poverty, disease, disillusionment and death. You
want to get ahead? You find yourself some horror. This was artfully portrayed
in Fellini’s La Dolce Vita, whose paparazzi were
odious locusts burrowing deep into the victims' suffering in the hell beneath
the façade of postwar Rome .
I know a fair number of journalists who quit the business over this inescapable
set of circumstances, over the continuous chase after whatever is ugly. They
understood they weren’t the cause. There’s something within the human psyche
that lusts for bad news. But at some point they just couldn’t take it anymore.
Journalists at prestige media -- The New York Times comes to mind -- tell themselves
they’re above the race to bad news, that they pursue greater ends and seek to
get at the heart of things. But do they? In the car yesterday I tuned into
NPR’s “Fresh Air” with Terry Gross. Gross’s guest was David Kirkpatrick of the Times Middle East bureau in Cairo . As the interview began she recalled
that when he was a Washington reporter she’d interviewed him on a
wide array of topics prior to his overseas assignment. Did he, she wondered,
get ordered to the Middle East ? Or did he volunteer?
This was his answer. I couldn’t believe I was hearing what I was hearing so I
went home and replayed it off the Internet. Yes, there it was.
Kirkpatrick: “I volunteered and now I probably am the luckiest journalist
working today. I arrived, I was on duty in Egypt beginning in January, I think January
9, 2011 .
January 10 I arrived in Tunisia where someone had killed himself by
burning himself alive and January 14, four days later, the president of Tunisia fled and then the whole region was
up in flames.”
Let's be frank. The answer was hideous, curiously devoid of
introspection and reeking of the most simplistic analysis possible. He thanks
his lucky stars that someone torched himself just as arrived and then, oh what
a gift, the whole region went up in flames. Apparently looking any deeper than
this was just not part of his job description and something he preferred not to
do. He never seemed to examine the true nature of hiw work or how he viewed it.
Dealing only with surface realities, his answer was downright creepy.
Apparently if two people
had set themselves on fire he'd have been twice as lucky. I have nothing
personal against this Kirkpatrick, but if he ever comes to my town I fervently
hope he has a run of bad luck.